Disclosure: This is a blog about how to make money blogging, and where we recommend affiliat programs for bloggers. As such, this post may contain affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that we have recommended. While clicking these links won’t cost you any extra money, they will help us keep this site up and running! Please check out our disclosure policy for more details. Thank you for your support!
FTC disclosures on social media can be confusing, and that’s putting it mildly. The FTC recently had a Twitter chat where they let users submit questions, which helped clarify things quite a bit. Below you’ll find some of the highlights of the FTC’s #Influencers101 chat.
Back in 2011, I was invited to spend a day at the Consumer Reports campus in Yonkers, New York. It was honestly one of the coolest days I have spent as a blogger. In addition to getting a tour of their testing facilities – which was awesome, by the way – we attended a discussion with Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos (where he was wishy-washy about whether or not Amazon would ever release their own tablet – ha!), and we had a sit-down with a representative from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which had just recently announced that bloggers needed to disclose all of their for-pay relationships.
The FTC discussion was fascinating but confusing. There were lots of questions about when and how to disclose (remember, social media wasn’t anywhere near the behemoth that it is now), and why it seemed like bloggers were being targeted more than celebrities and print media. I don’t think anyone walked away with a very clear understanding of what they wanted from us, which is a feeling that continues to this day. As blogging and social media have taken off, the FTC has so much more to police and there are so many unique situations that make it almost impossible to cover everything.
If you’re ever not certain what’s required of you in terms of disclosure, don’t worry – we’ve all been there!
Partially in response to confusion over what they want, and partially in response to their first-ever complaint against individual influencers for not following proper disclosure rules, the FTC had a Twitter chat last week and the takeaway was clear and concise:
I thought I’d go through some of the discussion points from the FTC Twitter chat, but before we get to that, here are two things you all bloggers should bookmark:
- The FTC’s Endorsement Guides – read this, know this, enjoy (?) this
- If you have endorsement and disclosure questions, you can email the FTC directly! Send your inquiries to [email protected]
This chat primarily covered how to disclose relationships on social media. (Check out our post on privacy and disclosure policies for how to address this topic in blog posts.) I thought the chat was really was educational, and I thought the FTC did a great job of clarifying many of their positions. I’m not going to go through everything, but it’s worth looking through the FTC’s twitter feed to see all of the 25 or so questions and answers.
The format of the chat was that users submitted questions using the #Influencers 101 hashtag, and then the FTC did a pretty good job of responding to them in the order they were submitted.
#Ad, #Spon, #Ambassador… What’s Acceptable to the FTC?
One of the most frequent questions was how and when influencers should disclose whether something is an #ad and what variations of #ad are appropriate:
Q3: As an #influencer, I often use #ad to disclose brand affiliation, is that sufficient? #Influencers101 #AskFTC
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
For Twitter #ad is sufficient as long as it’s easily noticed. #Influencers101 https://t.co/JLKtP3kFvz
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
But if #ad is mixed in with links, handles or other hashtags, readers may naturally just skip over all that clutter. #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
w/ multiple links & hashtags, #ad may go unnoticed, best to make it visible in the
beginning whenever possible. #Influencers101— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Q23: Is #ad the preferred disclosure to follow @FTC guidelines & regulations? #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Using #ad is great IF it’s placed where it’s hard to miss. #Influencers101 https://t.co/XIcQR4jMyU
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Q25: Can’t we just use the word ad without the hashtag? #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Yes, but must be visible and hard to miss. #Influencers101 https://t.co/FX1AukQ7EZ
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Q26: On options outside of #ad / #paid, is there a definitive on whether # XX partner or similar suffices vs. “is stronger”? #influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Yes, hashtag XXPartner should be good enough when XX is brand name. #Influencers101 https://t.co/L8OL4zbk8s
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
#ambassador is an ambiguous disclosure, not good enough. Not sure why a post from official corp acct needs any disclosure. #influencers101 https://t.co/G34RHPOoUq
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
You can say “Ad” or “Sponsored” but those aren’t the only ways to disclose. #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 21, 2017
Good example could say, “[XX] company just sent me a free game code, here’s my honest review.” #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 21, 2017
Or could say “[XX] company gifted me this game so I could review it.” #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 21, 2017
For video reviews like YouTube & other, the disclosure must be in the video itself, both verbal & written. #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 21, 2017
This is awesome. You CAN use AD without hashtags in your social media posts, as long as its meaning is clear and your readers understand that they are reading sponsored content. To sum all of that up…
Acceptable ways to disclose on social media: AD, #ad, #sponsored, #XXPartner – whereby XX is the brand name, or something along the lines of “XX gifted me this product so I could review”
Unacceptable ways to disclose on social media: pretty much anything else where it is not explicitly laid out that you have some type of relationship with a company, including #ambassador
What the FTC Says About Built-In Disclosures
So what about built-in disclosures? Turns out that built-in disclosures on YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram, via branded partner tools, are NOT sufficient disclosure and you must still disclose properly in addition to using those tools.
Q16: Re built-in disclosures: Is the “includes paid promotion” mark on YT videos insufficient? The “Paid” tag on FB? #influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Don’t assume that disclosures built into platforms are sufficient. #influencers101 https://t.co/wneH6p0smW
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
It depends on whether the tool clearly and conspicuously discloses the connection #influencers101 https://t.co/wneH6p0smW
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
FTC staff doesn’t think that the built-in YouTube and FB tools suffice. #influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
The same applies to built-in Instagram tool. #Influencers101 https://t.co/mxstG6iO8G
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
FTC Disclosures on Snapchat & Instagram Stories
Q9: In a series of short, disappearing posts like Snap or IG stories is disclosure necessary on all posts or just the 1st? #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
When all photos will be seen, disclosure on first one could be good enough if it stands out & viewers have time to notice it #influencers101 https://t.co/rD2cWWBBp6
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
FTC Disclosures on Pinterest
Advice for disclosing on Pinterest? #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
A superimposed disclosure or one in the description could work. It needs to be clear and conspicuous. #Influencers101 https://t.co/M1m7VCJvEm
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
This was my question and I’m still not 100 percent sure on the correct way to approach Pinterest. If you are posting affiliate links on Pinterest, it almost seems like putting “AD” at the beginning of the description might be all of the disclosure necessary, since the disclosure needs to come before the product description.
I may reach out to the FTC to clarify this, though.
FTC Disclosures for Freebies
Bloggers receive lots of freebies, so my other question was about how one goes about disclosing that they received something for free, though the brand did not ask for coverage and no money traded hands.
Q21: A company sends something for free. No demand to post & no pay. If you post bc you like it & use it, is that an #ad? #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Yes, it is an ad – if they send it to you because you’re an influencer or for you to review it. #Influencers101 https://t.co/O6rNWPnm7C
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Image Disclosures are OK
You CAN use an image to place a disclosure on your site, which is a change from what they’ve previously said about this matter.
Q13: Can an image be used for disclosure rather than text as long as it appears before links/ads? #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
Yes, if it stands out, followers can’t avoid it, and they understand it. #influencers101 https://t.co/LyqCfoxtor
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
It’s Your Audience’s Location That Matters
FTC rules apply to international influencers with large U.S.-based audiences:
Q11: How does the FTC view non-US influencers with a significant number of American followers? #influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
US law applies when it’s reasonably foreseeable that posts will affect US consumers. #influencers101 https://t.co/9mj07m2M5t
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
So, if posting about products sold in US, they should disclose. #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 20, 2017
To reiterate: I do not work for the FTC, this is in no way legal advice, and nobody has all of the answers about FTC disclosures except for the FTC. If you have questions about what needs to be disclosed or anything else along those lines, please reach out to the FTC directly: [email protected]
The final words about FTC disclosures for influencers:
Bottom line, when posting about brands you work with, make sure your followers know. Simply disclose! #Influencers101
— FTC (@FTC) September 21, 2017